Sold out - Penelope American Light Whiskey 17 Year Hi Proof Store Pick 750ml 125 Proof Limit 2

 

Sold out in no time! Huge thanks to everyone
For those who missed out — Penelope Havana Single Barrel is coming in soon. Stay tuned!
Thank you all

 

 

Penelope 17 Year American Light Whiskey HI PROOF Single Barrel — "The Original Formula" 125 Proof · 132 Bottles

For four years, Penelope had a formula for American Light Whiskey: 128.4 proof, cask strength, balanced.

The 13-year in 2021. The 15-year in 2024. Both bottled at exactly 128.4 proof. Both praised for their silky mouthfeel, their dessert-forward profile, their rare ability to deliver aged Light Whiskey without overwhelming alcohol assertiveness. The formula worked.

Then the 17-year came out in 2025 — at 138.8 proof. The 18-year followed in 2026 — at 140.2, officially crossing into HAZMAT territory. Same 2006 Seagram's distillate stock. Same distillery. Different barrels, different selection philosophy. A deliberate shift toward higher-proof, higher-drama Light Whiskey.

What happened? Light Whiskey, enters the barrel near 160 proof and is designed to slowly lose alcohol over time in humid, cool warehouse conditions. For 13 and 15 years, the barrels Penelope selected followed that natural arc — descending to 128.4. The 17 and 18-year selections came from a different pool of barrels, ones that defied that arc through warehouse conditions, barrel position, or selection strategy. Whatever the cause, the proofs jumped 10+ points between 15 and 17, and kept climbing.

But some barrels stayed the course.

This barrel is one of them. Same 2006 distillation. Same 17 years in second-fill oak. Yet it emerged at 125 proof — below even the 13 and 15-year official releases — because it followed Light Whiskey's natural aging trajectory to its fullest. Slow descent. Patient complexity. No manipulation.

What you taste is the original Penelope philosophy, extended two years further than they chose to bottle it: pear, baked apple, amaretto, toasted grain, creamy mouthfeel — the silky, balanced profile of the 15-year, with the deeper complexity that only 17 years can build.

This is the 17-year the formula would have produced. A single barrel, 132 bottles, naturally descending to 125 proof. When they're gone, the formula ends here.

 Aged: 17 years, second-fill American oak Proof: 125 (uncut, single barrel) Yield: 132 bottles